| Richard Seth Carnine (1841 - ) |
James Oscar Gates |
| Hanna Kate Smith (1844 - ) |
Inez Agatha Atkinson |
| Edgar Clayton Carnine | Hazel Emaline Gates |
| b. 16 Jun 1889 d. Tacoma, Washington bur. Tacoma, Washington, Mt. View Cemetery occ. edu. rel. |
b. 2 Jan 1898, Tacoma, Washington (Kitchie, MI?) d. 19 Dec 1978, Tacoma, Washington bur. Dec 1978, Tacoma, Washington occ. edu. rel. |
| Spouses: 1, 2 |